A Franchise at a Crossroads
2025 Season in Review: A Franchise at a Crossroads
The 2025 season was not what Cardinals fans have come to expect.
For much of the last two decades, the St. Louis Cardinals have defined consistency in the National League — competitive baseball, a strong farm system, and a culture rooted in fundamentals. But 2025 felt different. It felt like a season that forced the organization to look in the mirror.
There were stretches of encouraging baseball. Young players gained valuable experience. Certain veterans continued to provide leadership and steady production. But over the course of 162 games, inconsistency proved costly.
The rotation struggled to find stability at times. The bullpen had bright spots but lacked defined roles when games tightened late. Defensively, the club too often gave away outs that past Cardinals teams would have secured. And offensively, the lineup leaned heavily on power while situational execution came and went.
The result was a season that fell short of postseason expectations — not by a single bad week, but by the cumulative weight of small things undone.
Yet 2025 was not without purpose.
Younger arms began to take shape. Position players who will be part of the next competitive core logged meaningful innings. The organization appeared more willing to evaluate honestly rather than patch over problems.
In many ways, 2025 felt less like collapse and more like correction.
For decades, “The Cardinal Way” has meant development, discipline, and accountability. Last season exposed where that standard had slipped — and where it must be restored.
The question now is not whether 2025 was disappointing. It was.
The question is whether it becomes the turning point.
Every franchise faces seasons that reset expectations. The Cardinals are no different. What separates enduring organizations from fading ones is how they respond.
As 2026 begins, the foundation laid — and the lessons learned — from 2025 will matter far more than the final standings.
The record is in the books.
What comes next will define the direction.
If Cardinals baseball still means something to you, join us at The Cardinal Chronicle as we follow the 2026 season together.
— ray mileur
The Cardinal Chronicle