One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest: MLB’s Olympic Power Play Has Gone Too Far

The Cardinal Chronicle
St. Louis, MO
By Ray Mileur

One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest: MLB’s Olympic Power Play Has Gone Too Far

There are ideas that sound good in a boardroom.

Then they run into common sense.

Major League Baseball’s push to place its best players in the 2028 Los Angeles Olympics should have been simple enough. Baseball belongs on a global stage. The game has become more international than ever. The World Baseball Classic has already shown how much pride, passion and television energy can come from players representing their countries.

That part is easy to understand.

The problem is not Olympic baseball.

The problem is Major League Baseball apparently deciding that Olympic participation should become mandatory for selected players, with penalties attached for those who do not go along.

That is where this thing starts to feel less like a celebration of baseball and more like another cash cow being led through the gate.

According to recent reporting, MLB wants selected players to participate in the 2028 Games unless they have an approved excuse. A player who skips without approval could reportedly be placed on the restricted list without pay and without service time for a period that could run into early August, well after the regular season resumes.

That should stop people cold.

Without pay.

Without service time.

For not participating in the Olympics.

That is not patriotism. That is pressure.

It is one thing for a player to want to represent his country. Many will. Some of the best players in the world have already made it clear that wearing their national colors means something to them. That should be respected. If Aaron Judge, Bryce Harper, Shohei Ohtani, Ronald Acuña Jr., Paul Skenes or any other star wants to play in the Olympics, that would be great for the sport.

But wanting to go is one thing.

Being forced to go is something else entirely.

The Olympics should be an honor, not a work requirement.

This is where Commissioner Rob Manfred and Major League Baseball need to slow down. The league cannot keep talking about growing the game while treating the players like inventory. These are not jerseys on a rack. These are human beings with contracts, families, injury histories, team responsibilities and careers that can change with one bad pitch, one awkward slide or one overextended throwing program.

The players are the product everyone is trying to sell.

That is exactly why they deserve a real voice in the deal.

If MLB wants the stars in Los Angeles, then negotiate it honestly. Protect the players. Protect their salaries. Protect their service time. Protect their families. Protect their clubs. Protect their rehab rights if they are injured. Do not turn the restricted list into a hammer and then act surprised when the union pushes back.

That is not partnership.

That is muscle.

The injured-list wrinkle may be the most ridiculous part of all.

If a player is selected for Olympic participation but is on the injured list, he reportedly could be blocked from returning to his major league club or going on a rehab assignment until after the Olympic window closes. Think about that for a moment. A player could be physically ready to help his team, but still unable to return because of Olympic participation rules.

How does that serve the integrity of the major league season?

A club could be fighting for a division title. A team could be clinging to a Wild Card spot. A player could be ready to come back and contribute. But because he was part of the Olympic pool, he has to wait.

That is not baseball logic.

That is event-management logic.

And that is exactly the problem.

Major League Baseball appears to be looking at the 2028 Olympics as a marketing opportunity. Of course it is. The Games will be in Los Angeles. The spotlight will be enormous. The chance to showcase the sport on American soil with major league players is valuable.

Nobody disputes that.

But at some point, MLB has to decide whether it is running a baseball season or staging content for global distribution.

The regular season still matters.

The pennant race still matters.

The clubs paying these players still matter.

The fans buying tickets to see those clubs still matter.

If a Cardinals fan pays good money to see a late-July game at Busch Stadium, that fan should not be treated like a second-class customer because Major League Baseball wanted to dress up the Olympics with its biggest names. If a team loses a key player for nearly a month because he was selected for an international event, that team’s season can be changed.

And if the player does not want to go?

Under this proposal, he could lose pay and service time.

That is where the whole thing goes off the rails.

The league wants the benefits of Olympic exposure without fully respecting the cost paid by players and teams. That is the old story dressed in new clothes. MLB wants the stars, the television shots, the flag-waving, the social media clips, the corporate partnerships and the worldwide attention.

The players want tickets, housing, family access, insurance, protections and basic fairness.

Somehow, the players are being made to sound unreasonable.

They are not.

If the league is asking players to interrupt their major league seasons, represent their countries, carry the promotional value of the event, risk injury and potentially affect pennant races, then the players should receive more than a pat on the back and a hotel room somewhere outside the fine print.

Tickets matter because families matter.

Housing matters because players are not props.

Insurance matters because careers are fragile.

Service time matters because baseball’s entire labor system is built around it.

Pay matters because this is still work.

That last part seems to get lost whenever owners and commissioners start talking about the “good of the game.” Funny how often the good of the game requires players to give something up while everyone else finds a revenue stream.

Baseball in the Olympics could be wonderful.

Mandatory Olympic baseball with punitive penalties is not wonderful.

It is a warning sign.

The better path is obvious. Make participation voluntary. Build strong incentives. Protect salaries and service time. Ensure family access. Provide proper housing. Cover injuries. Make clubs whole where needed. Create a schedule that respects the regular season. Let players who want to go represent their countries proudly.

That would grow the game.

Threatening players with restricted-list punishment grows resentment.

There is also a larger labor backdrop here. MLB and the Players Association are already heading toward difficult negotiations. The sport does not need another fight that makes owners look heavy-handed and players look like they are being dragged into a marketing campaign. If anything, this Olympic issue may become a preview of the next labor war.

That would be a shame.

Because the idea itself is not bad.

Major leaguers in the Olympics could be tremendous. It could produce great moments. It could give baseball a powerful international showcase. It could create memories for players, fans and countries that care deeply about the sport.

But the execution matters.

You cannot sell Olympic dreams with a restricted-list threat.

You cannot celebrate national pride while docking service time.

You cannot claim this is about growing the game while treating the regular season as an inconvenience.

And you cannot expect fans to ignore the smell of money just because someone waves a flag over it.

This is where Manfred’s MLB loses people.

The league has a habit of taking something good and over-managing it until the joy gets squeezed out. The pitch clock worked because it improved the product on the field. The World Baseball Classic works because players choose to care. The Olympics can work if MLB respects the players and the season.

But turning Olympic participation into a mandatory obligation with financial punishment attached?

That is not leadership.

That is one flew over the cuckoo’s nest.

Baseball should be in the Olympics.

Major league players should be allowed to participate.

Fans should get to see the best in the world on that stage.

But no player should be forced into it under threat of losing pay, service time or access to his own team.

If MLB wants the Olympic spotlight, it should earn player participation the right way.

Not by mandate.

Not by punishment.

Not by turning the Games into another cash cow.

The players deserve better.

The clubs deserve better.

And the game deserves better.

The Cardinal Chronicle, in association with Gateway Sports & MiLB Today
Preserving the Past, Promoting the Present, and Projecting the Future.

Check out The Cardinal Chronicle for more St. Louis Cardinals coverage, daily farm reports, prospect updates and old-school baseball commentary:
www.cardinalchronicle.com

Graphic: Cardinal Chronicle