The Armchair GM - the Case for Joe Ryan

ARMCHAIR GM — The Cardinal Chronicle
Trade Rumors and the Case for Joe Ryan
St. Louis, MO
By Ray Mileur

The St. Louis Cardinals have worked themselves into one of the most fascinating trade-deadline positions in baseball.

They are not supposed to be here.

This was supposed to be a transition season. A reset season. A year where Chaim Bloom cleared payroll, moved veteran contracts, evaluated young players and built toward something bigger down the road. After the offseason departures of Nolan Arenado, Willson Contreras, Sonny Gray and Brendan Donovan, most national expectations had the Cardinals taking a step back before they took a step forward.

Instead, the Cardinals are right in the middle of the National League playoff picture.

That changes the conversation.

It does not mean Bloom should suddenly shove every prospect into a wheelbarrow and sprint toward the first big name on the market. That is how bad organizations confuse opportunity with panic. But it also does not mean the Cardinals should pretend this season does not matter.

Winning still counts in St. Louis.

That is why this deadline should not be framed as simply buying or selling. The Cardinals may need to do both.

They can sell from certain areas of the roster while buying in the one area that matters most.

Starting pitching.

That is where Joe Ryan enters the conversation.

The Minnesota Twins right-hander is the kind of pitcher who should immediately get the Cardinals’ attention if Minnesota decides to open the door. That remains the important qualifier. Ryan is not clearly available today. The Twins have not exactly hung a “For Sale” sign around his neck. But if Minnesota’s season continues drifting in the wrong direction, and if the Twins decide to take a harder look at their long-term roster picture, Ryan is exactly the type of arm Bloom should be checking on.

Not because he is a rental.

Because he is not.

That is the whole point.

The Cardinals do not need to spend prospect capital on a two-month patch unless the price is modest. A rental starter can help, but he does not fit the larger plan unless the cost is low. Ryan is different. He would not just help the 2026 Cardinals try to reach October. He would help the 2027 Cardinals and give the front office a legitimate upper-rotation piece while the next wave of young pitching continues to mature.

That is the kind of move worth discussing.

Ryan is not just pitching well. He is pitching like a dependable top-half starter. He misses bats. He throws strikes. He works with a starter’s profile, not a bullpen arm stretched out and dressed up as something else. His strikeout numbers are strong, his WHIP is excellent, and his track record is no longer a short sample.

The Cardinals have spent years looking for stable, controllable starting pitching. Ryan checks that box.

He is also the kind of pitcher who fits what this club needs right now.

St. Louis has had encouraging rotation work from Dustin May, Michael McGreevy and others, but this is still not a staff so deep that Bloom can sit back and act satisfied. If the Cardinals want to be taken seriously beyond simply sneaking into a Wild Card spot, they need another starter capable of giving them real innings against real lineups.

Ryan would do that.

This is not fantasy baseball collecting. This is roster construction.

The Cardinals can build around young position-player talent. Jordan Walker looks like he is taking the kind of step forward that changes the shape of a lineup. Masyn Winn gives them a foundation at shortstop. JJ Wetherholt is already part of the present and future. Alec Burleson has become more than a supporting piece. Ivan Herrera has value. The lineup is no longer just a wish list.

But young lineups need pitching.

They always have.

That is why Ryan makes more sense than chasing a short-term bat or adding another middle reliever while pretending the rotation has been solved. A dependable starter raises the floor of the entire club. He protects the bullpen. He shortens losing streaks. He gives the Cardinals a better chance to survive the part of the schedule where depth gets exposed.

Every good Cardinals team most of us remember had pitchers who could take the ball and calm things down.

That still matters.

Now, the cost is where this gets tricky.

Joe Ryan would not be cheap. Nor should anyone expect him to be. If the Twins make him available, they will be selling control, performance and postseason value. That combination brings a crowd. The Cardinals would not be bidding against themselves.

That is where Bloom has to be disciplined.

The Cardinals should absolutely call. They should absolutely listen. They should absolutely explore whether there is a deal to be made. But they should not let Minnesota turn this into a hostage exchange involving the very core St. Louis is trying to build around.

There are names that should not be in this conversation.

JJ Wetherholt should not be in it. Jordan Walker should not be in it. Rainiel Rodriguez should not be casually tossed into it. Liam Doyle should not be treated like loose change. The Cardinals did not spend the offseason rebuilding the talent pipeline just to empty it in June because the standings got interesting.

But that does not mean Bloom has nothing to offer.

This is where the “buy and sell” deadline idea becomes important.

If the Cardinals are willing to move players from the major league roster, the conversation changes. Lars Nootbaar is the obvious name. He is not a rental, which is exactly why his value would be meaningful. A healthy Nootbaar has on-base ability, defensive versatility, left-handed balance and team control. Those are the kinds of traits other organizations value, especially teams trying to build beyond one season.

Trading Nootbaar would not be painless.

It should not be.

Good trades hurt a little. If they do not, the other club probably did not have much reason to say yes.

But if the Cardinals can use a position-player surplus or a controllable outfielder to help acquire controllable starting pitching, that is a conversation worth having. Bloom already showed with the Brendan Donovan trade that he is willing to move a good player if the return strengthens the long-term foundation. The Cardinals turned Donovan into young talent and draft capital. That tells us something about the way this front office thinks.

Nootbaar could become the next test of that philosophy.

The same applies, in a different way, to the pitching staff.

Dustin May and JoJo Romero are natural names in deadline speculation because of their contract situations. Both can help a contender. Both could carry value if the Cardinals decide to cash in on expiring pieces. But here is where the Cardinals’ situation becomes complicated: if they trade May while chasing Ryan, they are not selling out of contention. They are changing the shape of their pitching staff.

That may sound strange, but it can make sense.

Trading an expiring contract and acquiring a controlled starter is not a retreat. It is a conversion. You are turning short-term value into longer-term value without waving the white flag on the current season.

That is exactly the kind of deadline Bloom should be trying to navigate.

Riley O’Brien is another difficult case. He has value. He has control. He has late-inning stuff. Teams will call. They always call about relievers, because contending teams lose their minds over seventh, eighth and ninth-inning outs in July.

The Cardinals should listen.

But listening is not the same thing as shopping.

If a contender wants O’Brien badly enough to overpay, Bloom should be willing to have the conversation. But moving a controllable late-inning arm while trying to win in 2026 only makes sense if the return is significant. Not interesting. Significant.

That is the standard.

Ryne Stanek, depending on how the next several weeks play out, could also become a more traditional deadline piece. Veteran relievers get moved every summer. If his market develops, the Cardinals should be open to it. This is where roster churn and bullpen depth matter. You do not cling to every reliever because he helped you in May. You identify which arms are part of the next good club and which arms can help you go get something else.

That is front-office work.

But Ryan is the bigger idea.

He represents the kind of target that separates real deadline strategy from fan-fiction shopping lists. Every contender would love Tarik Skubal. Fine. Every kid would love a pony, too. The price matters. The fit matters. The likelihood matters. The Cardinals are not in a position where they should be emptying the farm for one superstar arm, no matter how tempting the headline might be.

Ryan is different.

He is expensive enough to be serious, but not so unrealistic that the conversation becomes pointless. He is good enough to change the Cardinals’ rotation, but not so far outside their timeline that acquiring him would contradict everything Bloom has been building. He would help now and later.

That is the lane.

The same can be said, to a lesser degree, about Reid Detmers with the Angels. Detmers is another controlled starter who fits the idea of buying pitching without abandoning the future. The Cardinals should be involved on that type of arm as well. But Ryan feels cleaner because the performance and track record are already more stable.

The question is not whether Joe Ryan would fit the Cardinals.

Of course he would.

The question is whether the Twins will sell, and whether Bloom can find a deal that strengthens St. Louis without gutting what he has just started to build.

That is the needle.

The Cardinals should not treat 2026 like a lost season. The players have done too much to deserve that. The fan base has watched too much losing and organizational drift in recent years to be told that a Wild Card race is merely an inconvenience to the master plan.

But the Cardinals also should not act like one good first half means the future can be sacrificed.

The right move is in the middle.

Sell the short-term pieces if the market overpays. Listen on Nootbaar if the return brings controllable pitching. Do not trade the true core. Do not chase rentals at premium prices. Do not confuse activity with progress.

And if Joe Ryan becomes available, make the call.

Make several calls.

Push hard, but do not get reckless.

That is where Bloom’s first real Cardinals deadline could define him. Not by whether he buys or sells, but by whether he understands how to do both at the same time.

The old Cardinals model was never supposed to be about choosing between today and tomorrow. It was about building a club strong enough to care about both.

Joe Ryan would help today.

Joe Ryan would help tomorrow.

That is why he belongs near the top of the Cardinals’ trade-deadline board.

The Cardinal Chronicle, in association with Gateway Sports &  MiLB Today
Preserving the Past, Promoting the Present, and Projecting the Future.

Check out The Cardinal Chronicle for more St. Louis Cardinals coverage, daily farm reports, prospect updates and old-school baseball commentary:
www.cardinalchronicle.com