A Trade He Couldn’t Live With: And Walks Away
The Cardinal Chronicle
A Trade He Couldn’t Live With: Dick Littlefield Walks Away
St. Louis, MO
By Ray Mileur
There are trades you accept because it’s part of the game.
And then there are trades you simply can’t live with.
Dick Littlefield, a left-handed pitcher who spent part of the 1956 season with the St. Louis Cardinals, found himself at the center of one of the more unusual moments in baseball history in 1958. A journeyman by definition, Littlefield had pitched for multiple clubs since making his Major League debut on July 7, 1950, carving out a career the hard way—one roster spot at a time.
But late in his career, baseball asked something of him he wasn’t willing to accept.
In May of 1958, the New York Giants agreed to send Littlefield and $30,000 to the Brooklyn Dodgers in exchange for Jackie Robinson—a name that carried weight far beyond the game itself. Robinson, nearing the end of his legendary career, ultimately chose retirement rather than report to the Giants.
And Littlefield made a decision of his own.
He never reported to Brooklyn.
Instead, he walked away from the game entirely.
At a time when players had little say in where they went and even less power to challenge the system, Littlefield’s choice stood out. He wasn’t a star. He didn’t have leverage. There were no agents negotiating options or contracts behind the scenes.
There was just a man, a decision, and the consequences that came with it.
Littlefield officially retired on May 30, 1958, closing the book on a career that may not have been filled with accolades, but ended with something just as rare—conviction.
My Old School Take
Back then, you didn’t get to pick your destination. The game told you where to go, and most players went without a word.
But every once in a while, a man would draw a line.
Dick Littlefield didn’t leave behind a Hall of Fame résumé. He left behind something quieter, and maybe more meaningful—a reminder that even in a game built on transactions, not everything is up for trade.
The Cardinal Chronicle
Preserving the Past, Promoting the Present, and Projecting the Future.